Reader-nominated pizza restaurants

By
Posted on Jan 24 2025 in Features

Over 200 “Indiana Connection” readers submitted their favorite pizza places across the state. The bolded locations indicate a nomination from more than one reader.

A

Albion Pizza Depot, Albion

Armed Forces Pizza, Peru

Arni’s, Lafayette

Azzip Pizza, Lafayette

B

Bearnos, Jeffersonville

Bello’s Pizza, Madison

Big Al’s Place, Washington

Bill Bobe’s Pizzeria, Vincennes

Bobe’s Pizza Express, Washington

Bourbon Street Pizza, Bourbon

Brittany’s Brick Oven Pizza, Madison

Brooklyn Pizza, Seymour

Bruno’s Pizza, West Lafayette

Bubba’s Pizza, Fremont

Buck Creek Pizza, Dayton

Burt’s Place, Lafayette

C

Camel Crossing, Lafayette

Charlie’s Pizza, Dana

Charlestown Pizza Company, Charlestown

Chicago’s Pizza, Greenfield

Chicago’s Pizza, Seymour

Chicago City Pizza, Scottsburg

Chuckwagon Pizza, Swayzee

Cook’s Pizza, Wakarusa

Coterie Pizza, Garrett

Cutting Edge Pizzeria, Fairland

D

DeAngelo’s Pizzeria, Denver

DeLullo’s Trattoria, Cicero

Deerhead Sidewalk Café & Bar, Evansville

Down Under Restaurant, Syracuse 

E

East of Chicago, Warren

Elm Street Brewing, Muncie

F

Fat Dough, Corydon

Faytastic Pizza, Shoals

Fire Pizza, Flora

G

Gaslight Pizza & Grill, Huntingburg

Goodfellas Pizza, Henryville

Goodfellas Pizza, Wabash

Goosepond Pizza, Linton

Greek’s Pizzeria, Muncie

H

Holtkamp Winery, Sunman

House of Pizza, Hammond

Hunter Station Pizza, Sellersburg

J

JC’s Coal Oven Pizza Co., Granger

Jendy’s Pizzeria, Hanover

Jerry’s Pizza, Logansport

Jim’s Pizza, Kendallville

K

Kelley’s Bar & Restaurant, Celestine

L

Lakeside Wood Fire Pizza, North Vernon

Legacy Pizza & Bakery, New Albany

M

Magoo’s, Lafayette

Marcella’s Pizza, Wheatfield

Marlow’s Pizza, Wolf Lake

Maurizio’s Pizza, Brazil

Mazerella’s Pizza, Sellersburg

Mellow Mushroom, Carmel

Mister B’s Pizza & Wings, Evansville

The Monon Pub and Grill, Monon

Monster Pizza, Decatur

Mother Bears Pizza, Bloomington

My Pizza My Way, Peru

N

New Bethel Ordinary, Wanamaker

O

Oley’s, Fort Wayne

Opie’s, Chrisney

Overpass Pizza, Covington

P

Palucci’s Pizza, Cayuga

Papa’s, Culver

Pepperoni’s Pizza, Rome City

Pesto’s Italian Restaurant, Valparaiso

Pizza Junction, Huntington

Pizza Junction, Loogootee

Pizza King, Angola

Pizza King, Geneva

Pizza King, Greenfield

Pizza King, Jamestown

Pizza Uncommon, Madison

Pizzeria Venturi, Goshen

Poplar Street Tavern, Seymour

Portside Pizza, Columbia City

Prime Time Pizza, Lawrenceburg

Puccini’s, Indianapolis

R

The Red Pepperoni, Madison

Rocksteady Pizza Parlor, Warsaw

Rocco’s Restaurant, South Bend

S

Salvatori’s, Warsaw

Sandy’s Pizza, Fort Branch

So Italian, Brownsburg

Speakeasy Pizza, Orleans

St. Benedict’s Brew Works, Ferdinand

Strong’s Brick Oven Pizza, Lawrenceburg

T

Taproot Brewhouse and Company, Pierceton

Tark’s Pizza, Galveston

Teena’s Pizza, Pekin

Tippy’s Pizza, Winamac

Tomato Bar Pizza Bakery, Valparaiso

Trackside Pizza, Osgood

Trattoria Enzo, Laporte

W

Whyte Horse Winery, Monticello

Y

Yellow Tavern, New Harmony

Z

ZwanzigZ, Columbus

7 Pillars Brewing Co., Peru

450 North Brewing Company, Columbus

812 Pizza Company, Georgetown

1000° Wood Fired Pizza, Mount Summit